Skip to main content

Can a trader refuse to deliver my order because of an incorrect price?

You find a product online at a remarkably low price, place your order and even receive a confirmation. A few hours later, you receive a message informing you that your order has been cancelled because the price was incorrect. Can an online shop do this?

The answer is: sometimes yes, sometimes no. It all depends on whether there was an obvious or manifest error in the price.

An accepted offer is normally a binding agreement

When a trader offers a product and you accept that offer, a binding agreement is created. Both parties must comply with that agreement.

This means that a trader cannot simply cancel an order because they have changed their mind afterwards or because they would prefer to charge a higher price.

What’s a manifest error?

If the advertised price is clearly below a normal and reasonably expected price, there may be a manifest error in the price. In such a case, the trader may cancel the order and provide a refund.

An obvious or manifest error is a concept that is difficult to define and must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. If the parties cannot reach an agreement, it is up to the court to evaluate what a reasonably informed average consumer could have expected from the price. Among other factors, the judge will examine whether the offer was consistent with the market price, taking into account any special discount that may have applied.

A classic example is a misplaced decimal point

A PlayStation is offered at the price of €55.99 when the trader actually intended €559.90. A new PlayStation cannot be found online anywhere for such a low price, so it is likely that the seller will not be required to deliver at that price and will instead issue a refund. It would be difficult to challenge such a decision by the trader.

What can I do in case of a dispute?

Has the trader refused to deliver your order because of an alleged pricing error? If so, compare the advertised price with the prices offered by other webshops.

  • Is the price difference limited? Contact the trader and provide supporting evidence to argue that the offer was valid.
  • Is the price clearly unrealistically low? In that case, the trader will probably be entitled to rely on a manifest error and issue a refund.

In practice, it will be very difficult to force a trader to deliver a product against their will. The most pragmatic solution will generally be a refund.

Do you still want the product to be delivered? In that case, you will need to bring the matter before the courts, which will determine whether there was a manifest error.

Do you believe that a trader is attracting consumers with incorrect prices? If so, please report the matter to the competent authorities.

wiki 5